Sheffield City Council’s disrepair cases up 1,584% in five years

In this insightful article, discover how Sheffield City Council is addressing a 1,584% increase in disrepair cases over five years.

With housing standards being a hot topic in the UK, it’s important to understand why this increase has occurred and what can be done to address it. This rise points to deeper systemic issues within the housing sector, including a lack of investment in property upkeep and potential socioeconomic factors that might be affecting both landlords’ and tenants’ capacities to maintain and report problems.

Photo by Raygar He on Unsplash

The Rise of Disrepair Cases

Disrepair cases refer to any issues with a rental property that affect the tenant’s health and safety or quality of living. These can range from minor issues like leaks to major concerns like mould or structural damage. When these problems are not addressed, they often become worse, leading to more severe health and safety risks and further deterioration of the property.

According to a recent report by the Sheffield Star, the number of disrepair cases reported to Sheffield City Council has risen dramatically in the last five years. In 2014, the council received only 79 cases, but by 2019, that number had skyrocketed to 1,327. This exponential increase suggests not only a growing problem but also possibly an improved vigilance in reporting these concerns.

This increase is concerning for both tenants and landlords. Tenants are living in substandard conditions, which can lead to significant health problems and discomfort. On the flip side, landlords may face legal action and costly repairs. Moreover, the reputation damage from being associated with poorly maintained properties can have long-term financial implications for landlords.

The Impact on Tenants

For tenants, living in a property with disrepair issues can have serious consequences. Not only does it affect their health and safety, but it can also lead to a decrease in quality of living. These issues are not trivial, as they can compromise the basic human need for a safe and secure home environment.

For example, mold can cause respiratory issues, while a lack of heating or hot water can make a property uninhabitable during the colder months. These issues not only affect the tenants’ physical well-being, but it can also cause emotional distress and financial strain. The psychological impact of living in such conditions can be debilitating, leading to anxiety and a pervasive sense of insecurity.

Disrepair issues can also lead to a breakdown in the landlord-tenant relationship. Tenants may feel ignored or neglected by their landlord, leading to frustration and potential legal action. The loss of trust can make communication difficult, further hindering the resolution of these issues and potentially leading to more severe legal and financial consequences for both parties.

The Impact on Landlords

On the other hand, landlords may face legal action and costly repairs if they do not address disrepair issues in a timely manner. Under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, landlords have a legal obligation to keep their properties in a good state of repair and to address any issues that may arise. Neglecting these responsibilities can lead to significant financial outlays and damage to their reputation in the rental market.

If a landlord fails to address disrepair issues, they may face fines, compensation claims, or even prosecution. Additionally, if a property is deemed uninhabitable, landlords may lose rental income until the repairs are completed. This can place a substantial financial burden on landlords, particularly those who rely on rental income to maintain their investment properties.

Moreover, the increase in disrepair cases puts a strain on the resources of Sheffield City Council. With more cases to handle, it may take longer for tenants to receive help, leading to further frustration and potential legal action. This situation also underscores the need for proactive measures to prevent disrepair cases from arising in the first place.

Photo by Benjamin Elliott on Unsplash

Why the Increase?

There are a few reasons why disrepair cases have risen so dramatically in Sheffield City Council over the last five years.

Increased Awareness and Reporting

One factor is the increased awareness and reporting of disrepair issues. Tenants are now more informed about their rights and are more likely to report issues to their local authority. The accessibility of information online has empowered tenants to take action when their living conditions are not up to standard.

Moreover, with the rise of social media and online review platforms, tenants can easily share their experiences with others, leading to more awareness and reporting of disrepair cases. This increased visibility can put pressure on landlords and local authorities to address these issues more rapidly.

Lack of Property Maintenance

Another factor is the lack of property maintenance by landlords. As rental properties continue to be in high demand, some landlords may prioritise filling their properties over maintaining them. This can lead to a decline in property standards and an increase in disrepair issues. Over time, minor issues that could have been easily resolved can develop into serious problems requiring extensive repairs.

Moreover, with the rise of buy-to-let properties, landlords may not have the same level of knowledge and experience in property maintenance as professional property managers. This lack of expertise can lead to neglect and a failure to recognise the early signs of property disrepair.

Budget Cuts

Lastly, budget cuts to local authorities may also play a role in the increase of disrepair cases. With fewer resources, it may take longer for local authorities to address disrepair issues, leading to more frustration and potential legal action from tenants. The reduction in funding can also impact the quality and availability of support services for tenants who are dealing with disrepair issues.

What Can be Done?

To address the rise of disrepair cases, both tenants and landlords must take action.


Tenants have a responsibility to report any disrepair issues to their landlord or local authority as soon as they arise. They should also keep a record of all communication and repairs that are carried out. By doing so, they create a paper trail that can be useful in case disputes arise or legal action becomes necessary.

If the landlord fails to address the issue, tenants can seek legal advice and potentially take legal action against their landlord. It is important for tenants to understand their rights and the available legal avenues to ensure their living conditions are safe and healthy.


Landlords must prioritise property maintenance and address any disrepair issues as soon as they are reported. This includes conducting regular property inspections and addressing any issues in a timely manner. Preventative maintenance can often avert larger, more costly repairs down the line, and help maintain a positive relationship with tenants.

Moreover, landlords should also consider partnering with a professional property management company to ensure their properties are well-maintained and to avoid any legal issues. Property management companies can provide expertise and dedicated resources to maintain properties efficiently and effectively.

Local Authorities

Local authorities must ensure that they have the resources and support to handle the increase in disrepair cases. This may include hiring additional staff or partnering with private companies to help manage the workload. These partnerships could facilitate quicker responses to disrepair issues and potentially reduce the overall number of cases.

Additionally, local authorities should also consider providing education and resources for landlords to help them better maintain their properties and avoid future housing disrepair claims. Workshops, informational pamphlets, and online resources can be invaluable tools for landlords, particularly those new to the rental market.


The increase in disrepair cases reported to Sheffield City Council is a cause for concern for both tenants and landlords. It’s important for all parties involved to take responsibility and work together to address these issues. Through increased awareness, proactive maintenance, and better resource allocation, the number of disrepair cases can be reduced, leading to improved living conditions for tenants and more sustainable property investments for landlords. Tenants must report any disrepair issues, landlords must prioritise property maintenance, and local authorities must ensure they have the resources to handle the increase in cases. By working together, we can create safer and more livable rental properties for all residents in Sheffield.

More From the Blog